Say Cabaye to the Box-to-box Midfielder - (a.k.a. The Evolution of the Premiership Middle-men.)

Yohan Cabaye is dead. Well, not quite. He plays/ collects money in Ligue 1 now but for the 2 and a bit years he spent in the premier league he was a delight. A complete midfielder, able to pass, tackle and supply that little bit of magic with the odd wonder goal. But are players of his ilk a dying breed?  A box to box midfielder, someone expected to get forward but also track back. Is such a player a liability in these days of individual tactical responsibility and the battle for possession in the midfield now crucial.

In the UK at least, the notion of a general surgeon is long outdated. Surgeons are specialised. They do the same operation everyday and get damn good at it. Why would I trust a surgeon who hasn’t done this job for a couple of weeks when I can go to someone who did two yesterday? This idea of restricted freedom and duty is slowly being transferred into the world of Premier league midfielders.

Most teams now play a 4-2-3-1 formation, or some variation thereof. A defensive pivot of two defensive midfielders, and a number 10/trequartista to sit behind the striker. Think Carrick and Phil Jones behind Wayne Rooney. Or Flamini and Wilshere behind Özil. Or Lampard and Ramires behind Oscar... I could go on. Responsibility is distributed. This is most starkly seen in the Chelsea team, where the starting are separated in a back 7 and a front 4. The goalkeeper, 4 defenders and two midfielders rarely get involved in attacks. Whilst the front four, consisting of 3 attacking midfielders and a striker are left to go and try and score.

These new roles go hand in hand with the redefining of the full back. The days of the safe full back (your Gary Nevilles and Grahame Le Sauxs) are on the way out. Full backs seem to have less defensive responsibility than ever before and free reign to get forward and get involved with the attack. This leaves just the two centre halves as defensive cover from a counter attack, so it is only natural for one of two midfielders to drop back to fill the gaps to leave the team balanced. This is displayed well by Southampton with Luke Shaw and Clyne/Chambers often seen joining the cause up top with Victor Wanyama or Morgan Schneiderlin able to drop in on each respective side of the pitch.

SEE. Go through the top teams. How many box to box midfielders can you name. Oh. You think you’ve got some? Who?

Yaya Toure is perhaps the closest at Man City; but Dietmer Hamann (and I) would argue that he is purely attacking force nowadays. He loves to bomb forward. And I certainly wouldn’t argue that he is a defensive box to attacking box player. Great at making strides forwards. Turning defence into attack. But he is actually a bit of a liability when it comes to tracking back; more often than not it is left up to his partner Fernandinho to sweep up and hold fort at the back.

This certainly is a changing of the landscape of the premier. Most of the great premiership teams of recent years have had a clichē box to box midfield. Patrick Viera at Arsenal was the epitomē of one. Strong and well timed tackles, powerful runs forwards and decisive actions in the final third. Jose’s original Chelsea could be argued to have had two in Frank Lampard and Michael Essien. Manchester United had Paul Scholes, although he was much maligned for his tackling he had an exquisite ability to pick a pass and has a more than respectable scoring record.  

Whether this is a phase or a sign of things to come only time will tell. And in answer to your question; I do think of the title first and write an article to fit it. 

Manchester United vs. Sunderland - League Cup Semi-Final.

Manchester United/ Moyes in crisis. Repeat ad nauseam. 14 points off the top of the league and in danger of crashing out of the league cup; it’s been quite a while since a league cup match felt quite so important for a Manchester United side. But the place in the final and a chance at a piece of silverware for two managers with zero major honours to their name is no to be sniffed at.

Story so far:

Sunderland 2-1 Manchester United.

Gus Poyet’s men carry a slender advantage with them to Old Trafford this evening. In the first leg, 15 days ago: a cheap Ryan Gigg’s own goal late in the first half gave Sunderland the lead. This was cancelled out by a towering header by Nemanja Vidic. Parity only lasted 13 minutes before Tom Cleverly gave away a dubious penalty against Adam Johnson. This was brilliantly dispatched by Borini. That was that. However, due to the away goal’s rule Moyes’ boys just need a one-nil win to put them through to the final. The reward of a game against Manchester City in said final may not seem too appetizing though...

Key Clash:

Manchester United’s central midfield is much maligned this season. Typified by the abuse that follows Tom Cleverley and Marouane Fellani around and the constant speculation about other midfielders joining. But United have had periods of dominance in the majority of matches they have played this season (such as the opening twenty minutes against Chelsea on Sunday). However, far too often their forwards will miss a gilt-edge chance (such as Welbeck’s against Chelsea) and then their defence will hand the opposition a goal (such as Chelsea’s second and third on Sunday). The midfield is not doing too much different to last year, Carrick is still an excellent passer of the ball and the more combative Jones can still break up play. Whether there is a creative presence either in the number ten role or on the wings capable of creating enough opportunities to fire united through will be key. (See: key men). Sunderland’s central midfield is hardly celebrated for their creativity. Instead it is their industry which is noteworthy. If players like Lee Cattermole and Jack Colback can stop the link between Carrick and Adnan Januzaj then you feel this tie will be Sunderland’s.

Key Men:

Sunderland, Occasional maverick and one time alcoholic Adam Johnson is a man in form at the moment. Winning the penalty against united, followed by a well taken hat-trick against Fulham then a delightful equaliser Saturday lunchtime at Southampton. Call for a spot on the plane the Rio may be a bit premature but he certainly is a man who could have a big say in this cup tie. He is a rarity in this Sunderland squad, capable of moments of magic and will be crucial to a side likely to vent much of their attacking intent through counter attacks.

Manchester United,  “You’ll never win anything with Kids.” Well, to be fair with Aston Villa’s youthful exuberance firmly in mid-table and a side increasingly reliant on Adnan Januzaj looking more likely to join the mid-table scrap then the title push, Alan Hansen might have had a point. The 18 year old proud Kosovan has been a rare bright spark for united this season, and until Wayne Rooney or Robin Van Persie return (or a new signing is made) that looks likely to continue. He is fast maturing into quite the footballer, able to commit defenders, play a lovely through ball or finish with self assurance that belies his age. Maybe it’s the innocence or arrogance of youth; I’m not sure. But as long as it continues this is a player capable of causing Sunderland a lot of problems this evening.

Final Thoughts:

Years of conditioning have led me to not back against a United side whom only need a one-nil win at home against relegation fodder. Today will be no different. There surely has to be a backlash from this side, a statement of there’s still life in the old dog yet. There is enough quality in Welbeck/Januzaj/Valenica/Hernandez to score at least one goal against Wes Brown/John O’Shea. Whether one (or two) goals is enough will then come into play. Without Vidic due to suspension, Johnny Evans will likely start, his partner either Jones/Smalling. All talents capable of keeping Jozy “the human wall” Altidore quiet. (We’ll see if that catches on, he certainly displays about as much movement in between the lines as a wall).
This is there for united's taking, book their place in the final against Manchester City and Moyes’ and the articles of crisis will dry up for at 6 days until they lose play again. Respite.

Alternate World XI

The 13^th of January saw the crowning of the FIFA/FIFPRO World XI. Chosen by over 5,000 professionals from the world of football it aims to recognise the best eleven footballers on the planet. But what do these professional footballers know, in between training in the morning, quad biking through the countryside in the afternoon and pressuring young women into choices they’ll regret in the evening there is no time for them to watch a decent amount of football. Always keen to belatedly jump on any bandwagon; here is my alternate World XI. Besides, I have nothing else going on in my life and have plenty of time to watch and compare the world’s best.

There was only one rule: There are no rules no repeat choices from the original eleven. (So that rules out: Manuel Neuer, Dani Alves, Thiago Silva, Sergio Ramos, Philipp Lahm, Franck Ribery, Xavi Hernandez, Andres Iniesta, Lionel Messi, Zlatan Ibrahimovic and Cristiano Ronaldo)

Right here goes. Formation. 4-1-2-3-1.

Goalkeeper.
This one is difficult. As Neuer is actually quite far ahead of his contenders. Thibaut Courtois seems as sensible a choice as any. Winner of the Ricardo Zamora Trophy (lowest goals to game ratio in spain) and crucial cog in the triumph in defensive oraganisation that was Aletico Madrid in 2013. Maker of fine saves and consistently impressive distribution Thibaut is fast looking the complete package. All this whilst on loan from Chelsea. Petr Cech beware.

Right Back.
Possibly the most uninspiring this category has been for years. Dani Alves most certainly is on the decline. Lahm is excellent but vouched for (and on Pep’s midfield duty). My vote goes for tenacious Argentine (is there any other kind?) Pablo Zabaleta. A rare bright spot in Mancini’s uninspiring title defence for Manchester City, a consummate professional who has added real attacking intent to his previous defensive competency. An excellent all rounder who would improve any squad.

Left Back.
A freighteningly ignorant omission from the World XI was surely David Alaba. With Lahm’s move into midfield he now has a decent case for calling himself the best full back plying his trade currently. A man who has it all, goal-line blocks, pace, attacking intent and a whirl at set-pieces. No brainer.

Centre backs.
The snub for a central defensive unit who kept a clean sheet over two legs against Barca in the champions league semi-final must not continue. To that end: Jerome Boateng. The less celebrated out of Boateng-Dante but in this humble bloggers opinion, the superior defender. The mere fact that Dante sits behind comedy defender David Luiz in his national team means he’s ineligible for this squad. To partner him Andrea Barzagli. Having a world XI without an Italian defender felt a bit wrong, but more than that, Barzagli is just a very good defender. Stong, tactically astute and able to steal the ball from under the nose of any striker. A real toss-up between him and Chiellini though at the heart of Juventus’ and Italy’s defence, with Andrea just edging it in my book. Surely he’s better then red card Magnet Mr. Ramos at least?

Defensive Midfielder.
Any team worth their salt employs a defensive midfielder nowadays. FIFPRO’s Xavi, Iniesta and Ribery would offer little protection in an actual game of football. Step up to the plate Bastian Schweinsteiger. Wining 2013 German player of the year, and being described as Jupp Heynckes as the best midfielder on the planet are good enough credentials to patrol in front of my defence. He really does have it all (except pace, but the extra yard’s in his head, he inherited it from Teddy Sheringham when he retired) power, technique and leadership. A real german machine.

Central Midfielder.
The next slot needs to be filled by a box to box midfield type. So, he’s got to have legs, an engine, defensive capabilities, be able to pick a pass and chip in with the occasional goal. 2013’s best exponent of these virtues was surely Arturo Vidal. Helping Juventus win the league at an absolute canter the tenacious Chilean (journalism 101 being discovered here: tenacious *insert south American nationality*) deserves his spot despite being completely overrun by Bayern’s midfield in the champions league *cough* it certainly didn’t rule out Iniesta/Xavi for the real XI *cough* Excuse me.

Attacking midfielder.
It being 2014 nowadays, no team should exist without a number 10, A trequartista, a playmaker. The type of people that make football fun to watch. If it was up to me this role would go to Juan Mata. The little Spanish magician really is a joy to watch. He provides assists and goals in equal measure and seems a genuinely lovely bloke to boot. What’s that?  It is up to me? He’s in then. His positional sense is outstanding. His technique; breathtaking. And his beard; adorable. His decline to Chelsea benchwarmer really is heartbreaking to watch. #freethespecialjuan.

Right Winger.
Arjen Robben. Scored the winner in the champions league final. Monkey off his back. The nearly man (THAT World cup final miss. Oh dear) became the main man. He really is just a brilliant footballer. Ferociously fast and superbly skilful. Occasionally shot happy, but always entertaining.

Left Winger.
Gareth Bale sold his soul this year; sacrificing his creative side to become a goal machine. But what a pleasantly functioning machine he was. The scorer of more wonder goals per minute then anyone in the premiership since a certain Ronaldo graced the league. A truely brilliant season, and he started life in Madrid in a similar fashion. (alright apart from a very convincing ghost impression in el clasico). Well done Gareth; do the valleys proud.

Centre Forward.
Despite having his first trophy less season at Dortmund (and being a bit of a dick at following Götze to Bayern) Robert Lewandowski is an excellent footballer. He improved his all round game this year too, dropping deep in tough games and always linking up well with Judas Götze and Marco Reus. That and he scored a lot of excellent goals; and that’s what being a centre forward is all about.

So there you are. I reckon this team would give FIFPRO’s XI a right pasting.